Best Baby Mattress for Crib (to make sure your little one sleeps well)

Researching all the possible options for a crib mattress can be overwhelming. We've narrowed it down for you, making a short list of our picks for the best baby mattress for your baby's crib!

There are few things more precious to a parent than sleep. So, when you are purchasing a crib and mattress for your baby’s nursery, there is no doubt you are thinking about your sleep as much as theirs. Crib mattresses can be a tricky buy.

What is the right firmness? Softness? Are there special materials to avoid? With so many options, what is the best baby mattress to buy?!?

To help simplify the process, we’ve done the research for you. As you’re considering what the best baby mattress is for your baby, ask these three questions:

  1. Is it safe?
  2. Will it last beyond the crib and into toddlerhood?
  3. Will it help me sleep by making them sleep?

Here are our picks for best baby mattress for your baby’s crib, each designed to make sure your little one sleeps well (and you do, too!).

(Note: This post contains affiliate links. See affiliate disclaimer at the bottom of the page.)

Best Baby Mattress #1: Milliard Crib Mattress, Dual Comfort System

What I love about this Milliard crib mattress is that it is versatile, inexpensive and has amazing reviews. People gush about how comfortable it is and how easy to clean. As a mom of a child who has had one too many diaper “oops” in his bed, I can say this is a very helpful feature!

It is also inexpensive and competitively priced for the value making it one of the best baby mattresses you can get on a budget.

Pricing is not everything when talking about getting the best baby mattress, but it does matter. Baby stuff is expensive! And you want to make sure you are getting the most bank for your buck!

It has a firmer side for baby safety and a softer side for that transition into the toddler bed. So, the Milliard crib mattress checks all of my boxes for a great buy:

  • safe for baby,
  • transitions well,
  • and if my kid sleeps half as well as some of the previous purchasers, I am one step closer to getting a good night of rest!

Learn more about the Milliard Dual Comfort Crib Mattress.

Best Baby Mattress #2: Milliard Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress

Milliard also brings us our second-best crib mattress. This one is also made of durable and “oh-so-cozy” foam. It also transitions from baby to toddler with ease, however it doesn’t have the dual sided feature of the first mattress.

This mattress is waterproof so if it is dirtied, cleaning is a breeze. No stuck urine odors or stains!

Reviewers glow about the mattress being well-made and easy of clean up. The additional bonus to the waterproof outside layer, is it also prevents dust and other allergens from finding their way into the mattress foam.

Great for little ones who are allergy prone!

One concern I had about waterproof mattresses, is whether or not the material was noisy. I can’t imagine anything worse than the baby mattress being noisy enough to wake the baby!

However, let me put your mind at ease now. This mattress material is not noisy, especially once a sheet is on it. In the words of my toddler it’s, “nice and comfy!”

Learn more about the Millard Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress.

Best Baby Mattress #3: Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress

Now this is the Cadillac of the baby crib mattress world!

This Newton mattress is more expensive than the others on this list, but it boasts all the certifications, bells, and whistles to earn its place among the crib mattress elite.

This mattress is designed with safety in mind. The materials are 100% washable and made to be more breathable than foam or spring alternatives. This reduces worry about allergen build up and suffocation risk with very young babies.

The Newton Wovenaire mattress also carries the Greenguard Gold certification. This certification means that the materials in this mattress have the lowest VOC’s on the market. No part of the construction contains foam, glue, springs, or latex and it is 100% recyclable.

Parents who have purchased this mattress have put the breathability claim to the test and confirm you really can breathe through it! This makes the mattress perfect for anxious parents and babies who can roll over to their tummies for sleep.

Everyone is sleeping better as a result!

The mattress also states it can transition from baby to toddler with ease. It isn’t dual sided but since it is washable, it is built to last for years.

Even with the extra cost, I think all the bonuses and peace of mind this crib mattress offers really makes it one of the best crib mattresses on the market!

Learn more about the Newton Wovenaire crib mattress.

Best Baby Mattress #4: Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

If you are on a tight budget, the Graco Premium foam mattress might be the best baby mattress for you. This one is extremely budget friendly and comes sealed in a vacuum sealed packed, right to your front door.

The mattress itself is covered in fabric with a fire-retardant material. It is not waterproof or completely submersible, so make sure you consider that when going into the purchase.

It may be worth purchasing a crib mattress cover. Investing in a mattress cover will save you a lot of trouble later during the toddler and bed-wetting years!

Reviewers commented that when you first open the vacuum package, the mattress does have a chemical odor to it. In my experience, this is the case with nearly all vacuum-packed mattresses. They must be given 72 hours in a well-ventilated room to fully inflate and usually don’t smell the best during that time period. Most reviewers agree that the smell is not overly strong or long-lasting.

An additional bonus with this mattress is it comes with Graco’s 6-year limited warranty. So, if you are having problems with the mattress or it doesn’t hold up to normal use, you always have that in your back pocket.

Learn more about the Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

That does it for our list of the best baby mattress for baby AND parents!

Whether you are concerned about allergies, breathability, or budget these mattresses are sure to be a hit. Any one of these mattresses are sure to get everyone sleeping like a dream.

Which crib mattress feature(s) do you like best? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

Researching all the possible options for a crib mattress can be overwhelming. We've narrowed it down for you, making a short list of our picks for the best baby mattress for your baby's crib! Researching all the possible options for a crib mattress can be overwhelming. We've narrowed it down for you, making a short list of our picks for the best baby mattress for your baby's crib!

About Eric and Tiffany Matthews

We're Eric and Tiffany, the parents behind Cynical Parent. We're just normal parents who are navigating parenthood with both eyes wide open (probably because there's a kid yelling nearby). And of course, we're pretty cynical. Don't believe everything you read or hear, whether it's on the internet, or from a close family or friend (or even from us!). Every child is different, and what works for one may not work for another. Sometimes you just need to try and see for yourself. :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.